Designing the value proposition
Sub-criterion 4.1 asks how you design your products, services and their underlying value — deliberately, rather than by accumulation.
Most portfolios are archaeological sites. Layers of offerings added over decades, each justified once, none ever removed, until the catalogue describes the company's history better than its strategy. Design means the opposite: starting from a chosen customer segment, understanding the job that segment needs done, and shaping the offer around that job.
The job-to-be-done lens is the sharpest tool here. Customers do not want a drill; they want the hole — and often not even the hole, but the shelf, the tidy room, the feeling of competence. The deeper you define the job, the more freedom you have in how to serve it, and the harder you are to substitute.
Good design also chooses what not to include. Every feature added for one customer is complexity imposed on all; excellent offers are as notable for their restraint as their richness.
The assessment evidence for 4.1: show me a recent offering and walk me from segment, to job, to design decisions. If the story runs backwards — we had this capability, so we built this product — the design is incidental.