EFQM and Strategy Assessors

From ideas to value: the innovation pipeline

Creativity produces ideas; innovation produces value. Sub-criterion 2.3 cares about the distance between the two — and most organisations lose their ideas somewhere along it.

Think of it as a pipeline with four stages. Capture: is there a known, low-friction way to submit an idea, and does every idea get a response? A suggestion scheme that answers in silence is a cynicism generator. Selection: are ideas filtered against transparent criteria — strategic fit, feasibility, value — by people with authority to say yes? Experimentation: can promising ideas get a small budget and a fast, cheap test before anyone demands a business case? Most ideas need a prototype more than a spreadsheet. Scaling: when a test works, is there a route to real resources and organisation-wide deployment?

Diagnose your pipeline by tracing five recent ideas through it. Where did they stall? In my assessments the blockage is usually stage three: organisations that collect ideas enthusiastically and then subject each one to the same approval process as a factory extension. Innovation dies waiting in that queue.

Match the governance to the bet size. Small experiments deserve small, fast decisions.