Materiality: deciding what matters most
Once you know your stakeholders, sub-criterion 1.3 poses the harder question: of everything they want, what matters most?
The sustainability world gave us a useful tool for this — the materiality analysis. On one axis, how much an issue matters to your stakeholders. On the other, how much it affects your organisation's ability to create value. Issues scoring high on both are material: they belong in your strategy, your targets and your reporting.
The exercise sounds bureaucratic. Done honestly, it is anything but. It forces conversations organisations avoid: is data privacy more material than carbon for us? Is talent retention more material than community investment? You cannot answer from a desk — you have to actually ask stakeholders, which is precisely the point.
The trap is producing a matrix that flatters existing priorities. If your materiality analysis concludes that the most material issues are exactly the ones you were already managing, be suspicious. Real analyses produce at least one uncomfortable finding.
Materiality is how listening becomes selecting. And strategy, as we will see over the next days, is selection.